OBVIOUS SPOILER WARNING FOR BBC SHERLOCK. *if you care about that sort of thing to begin with.
Hi, currently going through the finale of BBC Sherlock since I've been binging it for a while and it's a show I happen to really, really like. I gotta say though, this last season has been really fucking rough. But this last episode is. well. it's something.
Prior to ever watching the show I saw Sarah Z's hour long video on TJLC, The JohnLock Conspiracy, and most of my knowledge on it came from that vid. It's also what got me interested in wanting to watch it to begin with, so when I remembered Angelo's Disney+ subscription comes with Hulu (thanks again for letting me leech off you my guy, I am forever indebted to you) I figure, why the hell not. And I'm grateful I did, the first two seasons were really, really good. The Reichenbach Fall was an amazing finale for the show, absolutely gut-wrenching. I would've been satisfied if the show had ended there in all honesty. But then season 3 happened, and I thought season 3 was...okay. It wasn't bad or anything, they made some changes I liked (such as introducing Mary, love her to death.) and some changes I DIDN'T like (such as choosing to not explain the mystery of The Reichenbach Fall, and also Sally Donovan just being inexplicably absent after season 2, and FUCKING MORIARTY.) but I think for the most part it was. passable. not as good as the first two but still okay at most.
But season 4, jesus, what is even happening. I've never witnessed a show fall off as hard as Sherlock has and it's killing me.
Oh my god I'm watching this as I'm writing and THIS NIGGA MORIARTY IS *STILL* HERE????? ???????????????/ HOW???????????? We all saw him blow his own brains out on that rooftop but I guess the fact that Sherlock is somehow STILL alive already implied the fact that Moriarty very well could have survived too. And I guess after endlessly edging and teasing us about whether or not he's still alive (If I hear the words "Did You Miss Me?" one more time I'm going to shoot myself I swear to god) and then finally deciding that, yeah, he's dead and not coming back, HE WAS ALIVE THE WHOLE TIME. LOVELY. PAWESOME. 10/10 WRITING. I'M HAVING SO MUCH FUN.
Also good god if they make this faggot say some more gay shit again I'm gonna kill everyone. It's so incredibly obvious that they want to make him the effeminate homo villain and I think anyone could smell the queer off this guy from a planet away. Subtlety is dead and Moriarty stabbed it twenty times straight in the heart.
Okay so no, he's not alive, this is a flashback. He's still dead. I fucking hate this show.
But like I was saying before this show loves to merely hint at queerness or have gay characters (is it even characters plural? I can name one canon character who's gay and that's Irene Adler) and even then the gay character it has is so entranced by how hot and sexy and mysterious Sherlock is that she turns from a lesbian to bisexual. I'm not kidding. It's used in a scene to imply that both her and John could make an exception in their sexuality for the sake of Sherlock since she believes that John's very much in love with him. Anyone who says this show didn't queerbait it's audience must be blind. But anywho it loves to dangle the idea of queerness in front of you like a carrot on a stick without ever intending to deliver on it at all. It's kind of frustrating, actually. I don't particularly like it and its beyond me how anyone could treat this show as progressive. Oh well.
As for the finale, I don't like it so far. One could go as far as to say I kind of hate it. It seems as if they haven't given up on continuously making John Watson suffer for The Plot I guess. At first I figured it was a means of showing his loyalty, that no matter how awful things get between him and Sherlock or Mary, he'll stay loyal to those he loves the most. I think that's a good way of doing that, but then you kill off his wife, and make a man commit suicide in front of him after he refused to kill him himself, and at what point does it just sort of get ridiculous. Sure, the writers used it to establish a rift between John & Sherlock and showcase how no matter the circumstances, their bond overcomes everything. But they've done it a million times, and I feel like it was a hell of a lot better written in literally any other season besides this one.
Speaking of that, I think they stopped doing it post season 3 which I'm grateful for, but I seriously hated when it turns out Sherlock had everything under control Actually and there was no stakes the whole time. Cheers! I remember getting mildly annoyed by the whole episode with the bomb and the train, it feels like it severely undercut how heartfelt Sherlock's words were in a moment where he thought he was actually gonna die since he could've just hit the off switch the whole time!! LOL!!! XD!!! Like could we please keep some stakes here, not everything has to be a trick. Sherlock doesn't have to be right all the time. That's another thing that mildly annoys me actually, the fact that Sherlock is almost never wrong, and when he is it's incredibly minute. I feel like having him be wrong more often (or just at least more than one or two times) could make him feel more human since the show is so hell bent on humanizing him. I didn't think the episode with Irene was godawful or bad (even if I have problems with it) I feel like having him somehow come out victorious when he gets beat in the original story was an awful change. He should lose sometimes, he should've lost to Irene.
And you know what else I'd like? EXPLANATIONS. EXPLAIN THINGS. PLEASE. I get this show is a mystery drama thriller thing, and I'm not saying I'd like it to hold my hand and explain every little thing to me like I'm three years old, but at least explain SOME things instead of just leaving them open ended and then making fun of the audience for theorizing about the show you refuse to elaborate on. COUGH COUGH. THE EMPTY HEARSE. I swear, this show loves to raise a lot of questions without providing you with any actual answers, truly lovely.
And Moriarty. God. Moriarty. I have mixed feelings on him because I sort of liked him as a villain in season 2?? I don't know, I hated him at first but he sort of started to grow on me a little and I see him as a sort of compelling villain against Sherlock, especially with how he basically lives rent free in the niggas mind. But after his death it felt like they wanted to have a new, Moriarty type foe with Charles Augustus Magnussen but I'm sorry Moriarty washes him. I think Charles is creepy, very powerful, and knows how to use power effectively. He creeps me out, and I think he's a decent villain but in comparison to Moriarty you could not pay me enough money to care about him. They just couldn't let him die for whatever reason, so why not just bring him back at this point?? They did it with Sherlock, why not him?? I guess you could make the argument that his presence is more impactful since he continues to haunt the story post-mortem, but would anything really change THAT much if he was actually still alive? Well, the more I think about it yeah some things would change, having him dead is sort of for the best in that regard. I just wished the writers would've quit teasing the possibility of him returning, if he's dead he's dead.
But let me actually finish this episode so I can give my full thoughts on it. One moment.
Post watching the episode. That shit was so bad I'm going to sleep. It's 4 am, I'm done wasting my energy on this.
TL;DR: just watch House MD instead.